8/31/2023 0 Comments Subvert definition for kidsIn the United States, this line of argument has been advanced by Abigail Shrier, a writer for the Wall Street Journal who published a book last year titled “ Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters.” The cover art is a drawing of a prepubescent girl with a giant round cutout where her abdomen should be. Had transition been an option during her own adolescence, Rowling wrote, she might have chosen it as a way to deal with her own mental-health challenges: “The allure of escaping womanhood would have been huge.” Rowling’s piece explaining her position “on sex and gender issues.” Rowling, who presents herself as a defender of bathrooms, dressing rooms, and other “single-sex spaces” against trans women, wrote that she was “concerned about the huge explosion in young women wishing to transition and also about the increasing numbers who seem to be detransitioning.” She cited the controversial hypothesis that some adolescent transitions may stem from a kind of social contagion. Later in the month, the BBC’s media editor, Amol Rajan, published his list of the five best essays of the year, among them J. “The court was correct to curb a disturbing trend,” the Observer wrote. “Other countries should learn from a transgender verdict in England” the Economist wrote. The decision effectively bars British children and adolescents from transitioning medically.īritish media coverage of the High Court’s decision was generally positive. The court ruled that children under sixteen cannot consent to such treatment because they are unable to grasp its long-term consequences, and cast doubt on the ability of young people between the ages of sixteen and eighteen to give informed consent. Such treatments can be prescribed to children given a diagnosis of gender dysphoria, both to alleviate discomfort that can stem from the physical changes brought on by puberty and to pave the way for later medical gender transition. In December, the British High Court of Justice ruled on the question of whether young people under the age of eighteen are capable of giving informed consent to treatments that forestall puberty. This happens when children act with particular independence when people challenge the norms of gender and, especially, when both of these things happen at once, as in the case of trans children. No wonder, then, that attempts to subvert these two categories make people uncomfortable and, often, scared and angry. These categories, it seems, are so central to the way we organize the world around us that we apply them to everything, including random dogs in the night. Wouldn’t it be more interesting to learn whether the dog was a longtime family member or a pandemic puppy, whether it lived with other pets, how much exercise it got or desired, how it tolerated last summer’s orgy of fireworks, or to learn at least the dog’s name? These are the questions I usually ask other dog owners as our pets sniff each other, but in response I am still asked-hundreds of times a year-about my dog’s age and gender. The answers do not inform the interactions between our dogs, nor do they tell a story. Every night, when I walk my dog, several strangers, similarly tethered, will ask me the same two questions: “Boy or girl?” and “How old?” The pragmatic meaning of these questions escapes me.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |